The Most Popular Magic The Gathering Fan Theories


Are you up to date with the latest Magic: The Gathering fan theories? Like you, I’ve scoured the internet and stumbled upon some fascinating predictions and intriguing compilations.

This post will dive into popular MTG conspiracies, from Atraxa Theory to Lore Theory, and talk about their ripple effects in the game’s community. Get ready.. magic is about to get real.

Key Takeaways

  • Atraxa Theory: The speculation surrounding Atraxa, Grand Unifier, and her relationship with the Phyrexians adds an exciting narrative element to gameplay and deckbuilding in Magic: The Gathering.
  • The Seventh Man Theory: This theory draws inspiration from a short story by Haruki Murakami and suggests that players can experience waves of fear while playing against intimidating opponents, adding a human component to strategy in MTG.
  • Battle and March of the Machine Theories: These theories explore potential abilities and interactions within the “Battle” expansion, including speculation about leveling up cards and unique abilities. They also delve into the storyline behind “The March of the Machine” expansion, which involves significant character deaths and card interactions tied to this narrative.
  • Lore Theory: This theory proposes that Ashiok may be a construct created by Nicol Bolas to manipulate other planeswalkers’ dreams. It also speculates on the impending conclusion of the Phyrexia story arc in MTG and its potential impact on the entire game’s lore.

Atraxa Theory

Let’s dive right into the Atraxa Theory, one of the most fascinating fan theories in Magic: The Gathering. This theory centers on Atraxa, Grand Unifier – a character who has significantly shaken up gameplay since her debut.

Many MTG fans are intrigued by her impact on the game, especially because she is commonly used as a Commander in decks focused on card-fetching mechanics.

The primary speculation revolves around her relationship with Phyrexians and their influence on her powers. Some players believe that Atraxa may not have been created by them but was manipulated or enhanced to serve their purposes instead.

This possibility fuels lovely debates within our community and adds much-needed drama to our deckbuilding adventures.

What makes this even more interesting is how these speculations give a different flavor to ‘Atraxa’ based decks during actual gameplay. It’d feel just like being part of an epic fantasy tale straight out of ‘Tales of Middle-earth’.

You see, every time you shuffle those cards in hand or strategically play your permanents, it feels like actively participating in shaping Atraxa’s lore—a unique experience only MTG can provide.

This theory further extends its grip towards Battle and March of the Machine theories as well, tying together multiple aspects of MTG’s intricate storyline to furnish a riveting narrative for all devout fans to revel upon.

What an exciting concept! Don’t you agree? My advice? Next time when engaging in a multiplayer game or studying metagame strategies online; don’t forget to factor the speculation surrounding Atraxa—after all, great lore enhances not just our understanding but also our love for this exceptional card game.

The Seventh Man Theory

As an ardent follower of Magic the Gathering (MTG), I find myself continually drawn to the fan theories that circulate amongst the MTG community. Let’s talk about one such theory, The Seventh Man Theory, which takes inspiration from a short story penned by renowned author Haruki Murakami.

This narrative revolves around a man’s harrowing encounter with fear itself, depicted through his brushes with death in merciless waves. Mirroring this concept, our beloved card game presents tales of warriors meeting their fate on battlegrounds shaped by players like us.

In correlation with “The Seventh Man,” this theory speculates how a player can become engulfed in waves of fear emanating from their opponent’s gameplay and strategies! It simplifies understanding how you could get intimidated when your opponent has rocked some stellar moves or drops some rare cards onto the gaming table; cards you might not have seen before just makes your pulse quicken totally relatable right? It adds an interesting human component to our game tactics — sometimes it’s more than just skill and strategy dictating who will reign victorious.

Joseph Davidson, another character in Murakami’s tale known for his low self-esteem and outsider status, is likened to many novice MTG players finding their footing amidst seasoned wizards – feeling overwhelmed yet determined to strive ahead.

Just as Joseph learns valuable life lessons through adversity in the story so do we learn essential gaming hacks through each defeat or victory we take home.

Like all good literature discussions, fan theories too are incomplete without an analysis of hidden symbols used by authors. Spot any parallels between ‘the running man’ in Murakami’s story revealing crucial plot details and those unassuming little cues notorious for turning tables during gameplay? Yes? Then welcome aboard comrades!

This unique combination of poignant fiction narration and fantasy card play not only contributes towards making The Seventh Man Theory popular but also underscores its emotional intelligence factor making it stand out among other prominent MTG theories.

Battle and March of the Machine Theories

Diving headfirst into the enthralling world of Magic: The Gathering, we find ourselves knee-deep in myriad theories surrounding the “Battle and March of the Machine” expansion. This recent release from Wizards of the Coast has sparked countless fan discussions and speculations, with an Alphabetical order twist on where “Battle” is mentioned on cards raising eyebrows.

A key point to note about this expansion is its focus on different planes, augmented deliciously by transforming double-faced cards. These new mechanics have genuinely added depth to gameplay, as players try to strategize around unpredictability – a little like trying to win a control mirror match while only working with half your usual deck.

Taking one step further into this theoretical abyss, some fans reckon that Battle cards could potentially level up or possess unique abilities – sweetening an already thrilling metagame for MTG enthusiasts everywhere.

Marching alongside Battle card theories are those centered around ‘The March of the Machine.’ The storyline here pulls no punches; it involves offing popular characters (I’m still mourning), leading fans into frenzied theorizing over card interactions tied directly into this narrative bloodbath.

Side by side they stand; two distinct game elements bound together by shared speculation and intrigue. As we delve deeper into these compelling fan theories and their potential implications for constructed formats in MTG, my excitement matches that eerie tingle you get when drawing just the right sorcery at just the right moment! Stay tuned as we unravel more threads from Magic’s latest sprawling tapestry.

Lore Theory

I’ve always been fascinated by the lore of Magic: The Gathering, and one fan theory that really caught my attention is the idea that Ashiok, a mysterious planeswalker known for their ability to manipulate dreams, might actually be a construct of Nicol Bolas.

This theory suggests that Ashiok was created by Bolas to infiltrate the minds of other planeswalkers and gather information for his own nefarious plans. It’s an intriguing concept that adds another layer to the already complex web of alliances and betrayals in the game’s story.

Another interesting theory revolves around the impending conclusion of the Phyrexia story arc. Some fans speculate that this event will have major ramifications for the entire MTG universe, potentially even changing some fundamental rules within its lore.

While it’s unclear exactly how this will play out, it’s exciting to think about what new possibilities could arise as a result.

On a separate note, I couldn’t help but notice some interesting Elden Ring theories floating around online. One hypothesis suggests that Ranni the Witch may have been responsible for breaking the Elden Ring in-game.

This speculation ties into larger discussions about unraveling mysteries and uncovering hidden secrets within fantasy universes.

Lastly, fan theories also attempt to make sense of certain aspects within established franchises like Zelda where things don’t seemingly add up or are left unexplained. These creative speculations provide fans with alternative interpretations and explanations while deepening our appreciation for these immersive worlds.

The beauty of fan theories is that they allow us to engage with our favorite stories on a whole new level, sparking imagination and inspiring lively discussions among fellow MTG enthusiasts.

It’s amazing how these theories can sometimes shed light on overlooked details or introduce entirely fresh perspectives. So whether you’re delving into forgotten legends or contemplating epic battles between ancient powers, keep those fantastical ideas flowing because you never know which theory might just hold some truth behind it!


In conclusion, the world of Magic: The Gathering is filled with captivating fan theories that keep players and enthusiasts on their toes. From Atraxa’s mysterious origins to the Seventh Man Theory and the intriguing Battle and March of the Machine Theories, these speculations add an extra layer of excitement to the already thrilling gameplay.

Whether they turn out to be true or not, one thing is for sure – Magic fans love delving into the depths of lore and uncovering hidden secrets within this magical universe. So grab your deck, prepare your spells, and let your imagination run wild as you explore these fascinating fan theories in the world of MTG!

Rumors and Speculation

I have been keeping my ear to the ground, and let me tell you, the Magic: The Gathering community is buzzing with rumors and speculation. Here are some of the juiciest whispers circulating among MTG fans:

  • There is a hush-hush theory that Ashiok, one of the characters in Magic: The Gathering, might actually be a creation of none other than Nicol Bolas himself. Could this eerie planeswalker be a pawn in a grand scheme?
  • Leaked rumors about Breath of the Wild 2, the highly anticipated game in the Legend of Zelda series, are causing a stir. Fans are speculating on what new gameplay mechanics and story elements we can expect in this sequel.
  • March of the Machines is generating plenty of excitement and speculation as well. This rumored new card type has players wondering how it would interact with existing cards and shake up their strategies.
  • Keep your eyes peeled for clues about the future of the MTG multiverse in Wilds of Eldraine. Fans are eagerly dissecting every card reveal, searching for hints about upcoming storylines and new planeswalkers.
  • If you’re into conspiracy theories, there’s one making waves in the MTG forum. Some believe that certain cards hold hidden messages or secret powers, waiting to be unlocked by intrepid players. Are these claims just wild speculation or is there something more to uncover?
  • In a lighter vein, fans on the forum can’t seem to stop talking about their favorite mob boss in Magic: The Gathering. Whether it’s reminiscing about great plays or discussing potential decks built around these powerful characters, there’s no shortage of lively debate.

Theories on Card Abilities and Interactions

As I delved deeper into the world of Magic: The Gathering, I couldn’t help but be intrigued by the fascinating theories and speculations surrounding card abilities and interactions.

It’s incredible how a simple combination of cards can create unexpected outcomes or unleash powerful strategies. Some theories even suggest that certain card abilities have hidden potential and can be used in unconventional ways.

One theory that caught my attention is the concept of “deathtouch shenanigans.” According to this theory, combining creatures with deathtouch ability with spells or abilities that deal damage to all creatures can wipe out an entire army with just a single blow.

Imagine the satisfaction of obliterating your opponent’s forces while preserving yours!

Another intriguing theory revolves around “counterspell hijinks.” Players have speculated about the possibility of using counterspells not only to deny their opponents’ spells but also to counteract their own spells for strategic advantage.

This theory adds a whole new level of mind games and bluffing tactics to the already complex gameplay of Magic: The Gathering.

These are just a couple of examples among many other intriguing theories on card abilities and interactions within this captivating game. Exploring these theories not only enhances our understanding of the game’s mechanics but also sparks our imagination as we consider new possibilities for deckbuilding and gameplay strategies.

So grab your deck, let your creativity run wild, and see what kind of epic moments you can create through cleverly combining card abilities!

The Impact of Fan Theories on the Magic Community

Fan theories have had a profound impact on the Magic community, elevating players’ experiences and fostering a sense of connection. These imaginative interpretations of the game’s lore and mechanics serve as fuel for engaging discussions and speculation among enthusiasts.

They offer players an opportunity to dive deeper into the world of Magic, exploring hidden connections, uncovering secrets, and crafting their own unique narratives. Fan theories create a vibrant community where ideas are shared, debated, and celebrated.

They not only enhance our understanding of the game but also inspire creativity and innovation in deckbuilding strategies. From crossovers with other beloved franchises like Lord of the Rings to intricate analyses of card abilities, fan theories inject excitement and intrigue into every aspect of Magic: The Gathering.

It is this passion for storytelling and exploration that truly sets the Magic community apart, making it a dynamic environment that continuously evolves alongside its dedicated fan base.

Debunked Theories and Lessons Learned

Throughout my journey in the world of Magic: The Gathering, I’ve come across some pretty wild theories and speculations. While many of them are entertaining to ponder, there are several that have been thoroughly debunked. Here are the top 10 debunked theories and the valuable lessons we can learn from them:

  1. “The Secret Hidden Deck”: Some players believed that there was a secret, unbeatable deck out there that only a select few knew about. Well, turns out, it was just wishful thinking. Lesson learned: There’s no magic formula for winning every game – it’s all about skill, strategy, and a bit of luck.
  2. “The Power of the Shuffling Technique”: An infamous theory suggested that mastering a specific shuffling technique could manipulate card draws. Sorry folks, but shuffling is random (at least it should be). Lesson learned: Don’t waste time perfecting fancy shuffling techniques; focus on honing your gameplay skills instead.
  3. “The Hidden Messages on Card Art”: Some players spent hours dissecting card art in search of hidden messages or clues about future releases. Alas, it was simply an overactive imagination at work. Lesson learned: Appreciate card art for its beauty and storytelling rather than trying to unravel nonexistent mysteries.
  4. “The Conspiracy Behind Reprint Delays”: When certain cards were delayed in being reprinted, rumors began swirling about behind-the-scenes conspiracies involving Wizards of the Coast (WOTC). In reality, delays happen for various reasons and aren’t part of some grand scheme. Lesson learned: Patience is key; not everything is a conspiracy.
  5. “The Secret Banned Card List”: A theory emerged claiming that WOTC had a secret banned list containing cards they didn’t want players to know about. But let’s face it – if a card was so powerful or problematic enough to warrant banning, they’d let us know. Lesson learned: Trust in the transparency of the game’s creators.
  6. “The Magic – Lord of the Rings Crossover”: Fans speculated about a potential crossover between Magic: The Gathering and Lord of the Rings, fueled by similarities in themes and lore. Sadly, it remains nothing more than a fan’s dream. Lesson learned: Appreciate both franchises separately but don’t expect them to merge anytime soon.
  7. “The Hidden Clues in Card Names”: Some theories suggested that card names might hold hidden clues about future storylines or mechanics. While there are occasional nods and references, they aren’t cryptic hints worth losing sleep over. Lesson learned: Enjoy the cleverness behind card names without trying to decode every syllable.
  8. “The Secret Error Cards with Game – Breaking Abilities”: Hopes were raised when rumors spread about elusive error cards with incredibly powerful or broken abilities floating around out there. Well, they’re just that – rumors. Lesson learned: Don’t waste time searching for mythical cards that don’t actually exist; focus on building a strong deck within established rules.
  9. “The Master Plan Behind Every Set Release”: Some players believed that each set release was part of an intricately planned storyline leading up to a grand finale or resolution. In reality, set releases are driven by creative decisions and player engagement rather than an overarching master plan. Lesson learned: Embrace the surprises and unpredictability of the game’s evolving narrative.
  10. “The Ancient Origins of Magic: The Gathering”: A theory proposed that Magic had ancient origins tied to


1. What are some of the most popular Magic The Gathering fan theories?

Some of the most popular Magic The Gathering fan theories include speculation about hidden storylines, secret connections between certain cards or characters, and theories surrounding the origins and nature of powerful planeswalkers.

2. Are there any confirmed fan theories in Magic The Gathering?

While the creators of Magic The Gathering have not officially confirmed any specific fan theories, they often leave room for interpretation and enjoy seeing fans engage with their own speculations and ideas about the game’s lore and mechanics.

3. How do fans come up with these theories?

Fans develop theories by analyzing details from card artwork, flavor text, storyline hints provided by official sources, as well as connecting dots between various elements within the game’s expansive universe. Discussions on online forums also play a significant role in shaping these fan theories.

4. Can fan theories influence future developments in Magic The Gathering?

While it is rare for specific fan theories to directly impact future developments in the game’s storyline or mechanics, Wizards of the Coast pays attention to player feedback and engages with the community through events such as tournaments and surveys to gather insights that help shape future expansions and updates to keep fans excited and engaged.

Alex Caldwell
Alex Caldwell

Alex, a former professional card player, brings his extensive knowledge and passion for card games to Progamecards. He believes in the power of strategy and the thrill of competition, values that are deeply embedded in our company culture. Alex's vision is to make Progamecards a community where card game lovers can not only learn and improve but also share their love for the game.

Articles: 19